SalarySwishSalarySwish

NHL Comps

Draft Class: 2024
Created By: NHLfan10506
Published: Jun. 3 at 2:18 p.m.
Description
Adding some NHL comps. Admittedly, drawing comps for draft picks is not my strong suit. Still a fun exercise. Feedback welcome.

Stylistic comps...not projection of career.

Ordered by rankings (not a mock)...but moreso in tiers (haven't finished full rankings)
ROUND 1TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
1Logo of the San Jose Sharks-Robert Thomas
2Logo of the Chicago Blackhawks-Brent Burns
3Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Quinn Hughes
4Logo of the Columbus Blue Jackets-Johnny Gaudreau
5Logo of the Montreal Canadiens-Mitch Marner
6Logo of the Utah Hockey Club-Hampus Lindholm
7Logo of the Ottawa Senators-Owen Power
8Logo of the Seattle Kraken-Patrik Laine
9Logo of the Calgary Flames-Alex Tuch
10Logo of the New Jersey Devils-Kent Johnson
11Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-Corey Perry
12Logo of the Philadelphia Flyers-Bryan Rust
13Logo of the Minnesota Wild-Erik Karlsson
14Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the Pittsburgh PenguinsArttur Lehkonen
15Logo of the Detroit Red Wings-K'Andre Miller
16Logo of the St. Louis Blues-Brett Pesce
17Logo of the Washington Capitals-Carter Verhaeghe
18Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the New York IslandersAlex Newhook
19Logo of the Vegas Golden Knights-Rasmus Ristolainen
20Logo of the New York IslandersLogo of the Tampa Bay LightningBrandon Hagel
21Logo of the Los Angeles Kings-Josh Norris
22Logo of the Nashville Predators-Sergei Gonchar
23Logo of the Toronto Maple Leafs-Ryan Pulock
24Logo of the Colorado Avalanche-Dominik Kubalik
25Logo of the Ottawa SenatorsLogo of the Boston BruinsIvan Barbashev
26Logo of the Montreal CanadiensLogo of the Winnipeg JetsRasmus Sandin
27Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-Kyle Okposo
28Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the Vancouver CanucksJT Miller
29Logo of the Dallas Stars-Carl Hagelin
30Logo of the New York Rangers-Max Domi
31Logo of the Philadelphia FlyersLogo of the Florida PanthersRyan McDonagh
32Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the Edmonton OilersTroy Terry
ROUND 2TEAMORIGINALPLAYERDETAILS
33Logo of the San Jose Sharks-Arber Xhekaj
34Logo of the Chicago Blackhawks-Seth Jarvis
35Logo of the Anaheim Ducks-Nils Hoglander
36Logo of the Philadelphia FlyersLogo of the Columbus Blue JacketsColton Parayko
37Logo of the Winnipeg JetsLogo of the Montreal CanadiensMikko Kouivu
38Logo of the Utah Hockey Club-Tanner Pearson
39Logo of the Ottawa Senators-TJ Oshie
40Logo of the Seattle Kraken-Michael Rasmussen
41Logo of the Calgary Flames-Brady Skjei
42Logo of the San Jose SharksLogo of the New Jersey DevilsLane Hutson
43Logo of the Buffalo Sabres-Trevor Moore
44Logo of the Pittsburgh PenguinsLogo of the Philadelphia FlyersNiklas Hjalmarsson
45Logo of the Minnesota Wild-David Rundblad
46Logo of the Pittsburgh Penguins-Jeff Skinner
47Logo of the Detroit Red Wings-Travis Sanheim
48Logo of the St. Louis Blues-David Backes
49Logo of the Utah Hockey ClubLogo of the Washington CapitalsErik Johnson
50Logo of the Chicago BlackhawksLogo of the New York IslandersAdam Henrique
51Logo of the Philadelphia Flyers-Mikey Anderson
52Logo of the Washington CapitalsLogo of the Vegas Golden KnightsMartin Fehervary
53Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Tampa Bay LightningAdam Boqvist
54Logo of the New York IslandersLogo of the Los Angeles KingsNoah Cates
55Logo of the Nashville Predators-Ruslan Iskhakov
56Logo of the St. Louis BluesLogo of the Toronto Maple Leafs
57Logo of the Montreal CanadiensLogo of the Colorado Avalanche
58Logo of the Anaheim DucksLogo of the Boston Bruins
59Logo of the Nashville PredatorsLogo of the Winnipeg Jets
60Logo of the Carolina Hurricanes-
61Logo of the New York IslandersLogo of the Vancouver Canucks
62Logo of the Calgary FlamesLogo of the Dallas Stars
63Logo of the Seattle KrakenLogo of the New York Rangers
64Logo of the Edmonton Oilers-
65Logo of the Utah Hockey ClubLogo of the Florida Panthers

Top Comments

Jun. 3 at 2:53 p.m.
#1
Avatar of the user
Joined: Jun. 2021
Posts: 17,192
Likes: 13,229
MBN - Corey Perry comp 😮‍💨

Inject it into my veins
NHLfan10506 liked this.
Jun. 3 at 4:11 p.m.
#2
Avatar of the user
Joined: Jan. 2018
Posts: 17,408
Likes: 12,503
Size aside, the Silayev/Power comparison just doesn't hold up at all. Two totally different styles of player.
NHLfan10506 liked this.
Jun. 3 at 5:01 p.m.
#3
free ville
Avatar of the user
Joined: Aug. 2020
Posts: 2,182
Likes: 693
I actually like these. The ones I would change are:

Levshunov = Lindholm
Stiga = Kopitar
Dickinson = Hanifin
Lindstrom = Hintz (though Tuch isn't terrible either)
Bednarik = Philip Dantanen (this is Danault and Rantanen combined -> Bednarik has Rantanen passing and skating but also has Danault's defensive game and skill)
Elick = DeMelo
Sahlin Wallenius = if we were talking current NHLers, Mintyukov

The rest look reasonable, you are spot on with Helenius, Surin, and Eiserman. For MBN I was thinking more Brady Tkachuk but I love the Perry comp even better!
NHLfan10506 liked this.
Jun. 3 at 7:20 p.m.
#4
free ville
Avatar of the user
Joined: Aug. 2020
Posts: 2,182
Likes: 693
Quoting: Claesson4Norris
Size aside, the Silayev/Power comparison just doesn't hold up at all. Two totally different styles of player.


Silayev is more Ekholm or Chara.
Jun. 4 at 9:25 a.m.
#5
Avatar of the user
Joined: Jun. 2022
Posts: 1,564
Likes: 499
The top 15... some of them are a bit ???

Levshunov is smaller than Burns and I don't think has that kind of offensive potential... it's hard to give that guy a comparison because coaches will want to try to mold him to fit a playstyle in their system, so he could end up being a 30 or a 60 point player, depending on what coaches want him to do. He reminds me a lot of Adam Larsson, who was also pretty playdoh when NJ drafted him. His offensive ceiling is much higher than Larsson (that is, what Larsson's ended up being because he was molded to be a more rugged D who wins puck battles and makes breakout passes), but I think it strongly depends on his coach. If he's going to play next to, in Anaheim's case, one of their power play young guns on left side, he's probably going to just complement them.

Zeev plays more of an every-man game... like a Noah Dobson on the left side. Quinn is a vision skatey guy.

Demidov plays a lot like Jack Hughes... talent-wise, though I'm not sure he has Jack's vision (like maybe two people in the league do), but he certainly has the feet and the hands comparable.

Catton reminds me of Sakic a lot... only difference might be playoff performance... Quebec/Colorado didn't know they were getting that when they drafted him, though.

Silayev is hard to gauge... he's mobile like Power, but he plays rougher, but not as rough as Chara did, and I'm fair sure he doesn't have the same offensive potential Power does. But at his size, if he has that dominating personality, he could end up being something like a Pronger, or he could end up just being something like a taller Bouwmeester. Guys playing in men's leagues are really hard to gauge if they're not in important roles... (same problem with Ustinkov, Solberg, and Artamonov

Eiserman reminds me of Brett Hull... because of his effectiveness as a shooter, gets kind of lazy. As the result, he'll be a 50 goal scorer you'll have to find the right linemates for (high maintenance), like a bigger version of Debrincat, but more effective at winning puck battles. A lot of snipers are reticent about puck battles these days. So he'll be a coach's headache, but coach can't say anything because he just flat out gives the team a better chance to win because he only has to work half as hard as everyone else to score.

Lindstrom... Evander Kane... big player, can shoot haaard. He's kind of braggy, so he's probably gonna piss a few people off, and then he'll develop an edge, supposing he can stay healthy. Keith Primeau also similar to him... he's big, but he's not Lindros/Ovechkin/Slafkovsky big. He's more Primeau big, Matthews big.

Corey Perry comparison with Nygard is excellent, Thomas is pretty spot on for Celebrini, Lindholm for Dickinson, Johnson for Connelly, and a lot of the guys in the rest of the first round are pretty similar.

Last one... Tij may be similar to Rust in size, but has considerably higher ceiling, and will play with a fiercer intensity. His playoff / U18 performance suggests he's going to have Jarome's knack for playing harder and heavier the harder and heavier games get.
See All