Quoting: thekingof8
This isn't a one-off. Dorion has badly managed assets ever since he took over as gm. Zibanejad-Brassard, trading a 2nd for Derek Stepan, the reach on Boucher, trading for Debrincat not knowing if he wanted to sign long term, and now he has backed himself into a corner with the Pinto situation. Yes we have a solid core, but, as we saw last year, if any one of them are out for a significant amount of time, we're screwed.
Zibanejad was traded because Melnyk couldn't afford his next contract. Also, there is some revisionist history here too, since I remember the talk at the time in the fan base was that he seemed more interested in being a DJ than applying himself to hockey.
What players taken after Boucher has been stellar, other than Wyatt Johnson? Sillenger with his whopping 3 goals last season? Barely any have played in the NHL.
I'm fine with the Debrincat trade. Giroux cited it as a reason he signed with Ottawa. And after years of rebuilds and trading away players, we made a play to try and got one. It didn't work out. Now we have a 1stnrd pick and Kubalik, who looks like he's playing well and fitting in so far.
He mishandled the Pinto situation, and it will likely be his make or break situation.
I got the point of the Stepan acquisition, but a 2nd was too much.
He's made good moves, he's made bad moves. He's had some good drafts, he's nhad some bad ones. He managed to get a lot of talented players to sign up long-term, and he's overpaid for some others. He's had to work with a barebones hockey ops dept and a seriously frugal owner.
Happens to every GM. Look at the haul JBB have away for Jeannot. The terrible FA signings by Yzerman.
Andlauer believes in accountability. As long as he sees fit to keep him around, I'll assume he's doing a good job enough job with the resources and mandate given