How bout Nylander for Manson?

hell no

Gibson is untouchable unless one of Matthews or Marner is involved.

you want a top 3/top 10 scorer in the league for a goalie who is middle of the pack in save percentage?

If he’s the middle of the pack, why trade for him? We’ll just keep him then if he’s so mediocre.

because he's still better than andersen. i like him but he's no vasilevskiy.

Yeah that would never happen, people often understate goalies in trades on here but the point does stand that a franchise goalie doesn’t bring back franchise players, frankly I think this package isn’t too bad, however I do think this wouldn’t happen unless Gibby requests a trade, only thing I may change is I feel like a first would have to be included, whether that be in exchange for the two seconds or one of them upgrades idk, maybe you remove the two seconds add in a first and make a conditional second that is granted if the leafs pass round one, idk, I think overall though this is a decent deal that may just need tinkering

Also niemela might be nice to receive, I like him