Quoting: Habs4ever
Excellent reply worthy of dissertation on my part. I was surprised when Skinner was given such a big contract and you are correct defensively he is not a stalwart. Jason Botterill. It takes time to be a good GM. Julien Brisebois was taken under the wing of Bob gainey and then Yzerman. Marc bergevin made some bad trades and drafts from 2012 to 2016. Since 2017 he has a much better tract record. So was Jason going to get better in time? perhaps! who knows. I do know from first hand knowledge the the owners wife interferes a lot.
The only area I will disagree with you is about Ryan O'Reilly. I know his grandmother, parents, older brother well. The only one I do not know well is the sister. Ryan stayed at my house and I coached him twice. I have known him since he was sixteen years old. Snook (his childhood nickname) is absolute gold. Hundreds of times he asked me after practice to feed him fifty to 75 pucks to he could work on his one timer, his release, backhand. He wanted out of Buffalo, because he had no idea who was in charge and where the boat was going. Again, I preface the owner and his wife. If he was a "cancer" as you say, why did St Louis name him captain? In the summer I used to have a very large dryland training program with 400 athletes. Players from Manitoba to Newfoundland and Americans attended. My wife who loves to cook, would arrange all the meals along with some of her friends, that we allowed their sons to be in the camps for free in exchange for their help in the kitchen. My wife said Ryan O'Reilly was always very polite and respectful. So, I know that I know Ryan is not a "cancer". TEAM Canada would not keep calling him if he was one!
but the rest of the post, you have some excellent points.
It may have been true that he wanted out, but i was more trying to say, the Sabres had to move him before July 1st if I am not mistaken otherwise they would have been on the hook for his bonus, and I do know that Terry Pegula is a fan, and tends to make decisions and run the team one.
He likey did want out, but half of the fans, and the team likely believed that he was a cancer, which, no I dont believe ever was true, and because of all that was going on around town, and after his infamous comments, I believe (speculation of course) the ownership fast tracked his traded to beat that deadline. Had the Sabres waited or been more patient, they likely could have gotten a better prospect or player in return, but you back yourself into a corner and give yourself no leverage when the entire league knows you are trying to trade him to beat a deadline.
And here is the thing, back when people we're speculating on moving ROR, my question for them was" who was going to log all this minutes and in every situation, it wasn't just about "faceoffs" as was the running joke around here. And instead we ended up rushing Casey Mittelstadt's development. Its a shame that played out the way it did because ROR was a great player and I was excited when we acquired him.
I agree that O'Reilly didn't know who was in charge in the Sabres. The front office and Pegula Sports and Entertainent is known to be a mess, but im sure the Pegula's are also making a lot of hockey decisions that they shoudn't be making which is what made the Kevyn Adams hire interesting. Is he a guy they think they can control, similar to when Ralph Wilson hired Marv Levy to be GM back in 2006 because he wanted to be listened to when he wanted to do stuff like draft a kicker? Or is he a guy that they trust and will listen to if he has input or reservations about a player, hockey decision, or transaction?