Quoting: HockeyNM1510
No cap space for Matthews and Marner. Underpaying Nylander. Edmonton laughs. Tavares isn’t signing for cheap money to be the 3rd LINE CENTER. He’s not signing to play BEHIND NAZEM KADRI. Come on. What a joke. -100000000 stars
I hear what you are saying...although I think giving it more negative stars the the US National debt is too extreme.
There is certainly Cap space for Matthews and Marner if we are using annual Cup favourite Tampa Bay as the template and not sucky run teams like Buffalo and Edmonton. Marner can't hold a candle to Kucherov who recently signed a $4.8 MIL bridge deal in Tampa Bay. Tavares isn't as good as Stamkos who signed an $8.5 MIL long term deal as a UFA.
Look at MacKinnon, 6'3" Sheifele and 6'3" Monahan all signed long term to a little over $6 MIL each. Can NHL hockey fans here say that Matthews is significantly better than them....with a straight face?? I am a passionate Leafs fan and I haven't been this excited since the 70s as a kid but I find Leaf fans are extreme in their opinions of our players...how good a player is and how bad a player is.
The Leafs have a good core of young forwards and a decent goalie with okay defencemen but they haven't won anything yet. They aren't the best team on paper. They aren't even the best team on the ice. We are at best 6th. I don't understand why some fans here are so crazy with the amounts they suggest these unproven players should be given coming off their ELCs.
As for 1C, 2C and 3C you can arrange it how you like:
Marleau / Tavares / Kapanen
Hyman / Matthews / Nylander
Johnsson / Kadri / Marner
Martin / Komarov / Leivo
...I don't care.
The issue is the depth down the center which would be a luxury that the Leafs can't afford Cap-wise if the players and management don't sign Tampa Bay style contracts. Simple as that.