Quoting: NickC1988
It's not bad, but STL still needs to add.
I don't like trades where the greedy party (in this case, me) just gives you 5 nickles for a quarter. You know where I just pick the things I don't like about my team and offer them to you for something I want. I try to avoid that.
From STL's point of view Sam is due a hefty raise next season (on final ELC season) and isn't playing top 6 C right now. Depending on continued improvement he could shoot from 3 mil AAV up to as much as 5 mil AAV. STL can absorb this cost due to Paul Stastny leaving next season.
But the two pieces offered:
Barbashev (a 2-way C) spent some playoff time as the teams 1C and has 1 more year of sub 1mil AAV. No fan glasses on, seriously, he is a legit 3C.
Walman has his full 3 year ELC for any receiving team and arguably a solid farm systems top prospect at this time.
So while I do respect that Buf would want more (and could maybe get more!
), I feel any further add would be a net loss for STL, thus preventing a win-win trade.
I think STL would have to respectfully pass from an additional add at this time.